Showing posts with label Vice President. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Vice President. Show all posts

Friday, October 3, 2008

It's the questions, stupid

For weeks, Republicans told us the culprit in Sarah Palin's dismal interview performances were the questions. Tonight, her relative success in the vice presidential debate could also be attributed to the questions.

By now most people have seen the 500 video clips of Katie Couric's interview of Sarah Palin that CBS has been dribbling out over the last week or so. The cringe-inducing performances even had conservatives questioning her openly. Of course, the right wing faithful told us the real problem were the questions. They were gotcha questions.

Q:What newspapers do you read?
Rep: Foul! No one would ask that of a man.
Q: Name a Supreme Court decision you don't agree with?
Rep: Foul! She is an outsider and didn't need to concern herself with supreme court decisions. That's not something a president needs to know, they said with straight faces.

During the debate however, Palin benefited from Gwen Ifill's boringly predictable questions. It was as if she went to the campaign websites and turned their policy papers into questions. They were all so utterly predictable. None made you look at the subject from a different perspective. None seemed to be designed to elicit a thoughtful response, so she rarely got any.

Of course this suited Sarah Palin just fine. Now she could recite her talking points with generous helping of "Golly Gee Beav..." At one point when Joe Biden was responding you could see Sarah Palin giggling to herself with that giddy "she's asking all my questions" smile.

Traditional media training always emphasizes that it's not the questions that sink you, it's the answers. In Palin's case, the questions are the ones that help her sink or swim.

Friday, September 26, 2008

Some unsolicited advice to Palin's PR people

I'm not in the habit of giving Republican operatives advice, but after watching Sarah Palin's interview with Katie Couric I just have to say:

STOP LETTING HER DO NATIONAL INTERVIEWS. STOP IT!!!

I know you needed to get her out there eventually. It was getting to be embarrassing the way you were shielding her. You introduced her as someone who was ready to be president but not do interviews. The embarrassment was not that she couldn't do interveiws, it was that YOU didn't think she could do interviews. If you don't have confidence in her, why should we?

After watching the debacles with Charlie Gibson and Katie Couric, it seems your lack of confidence was well founded. After four weeks of being sequestered for cram sessions, she still doesn't have a coherent answer to ANY question. I can't think of a single answer that inspired my confidence.

Now...it's not that Palin's people have asked for my advice nor would they, but here it is...

Let Sarah Palin only do local interviews with small time news outlets. Let her do one in every small town you visit. You gain three things:

1) You have the illusion that she is out there talking to the press. Then you can make a legitimate claim that she is doing interviews with the real people...the people who matter. You do a couple of these local interviews each week, and the national outlets will carry them. They will mutter with jealousy, but they'll carry them. You don't have to talk to Wolf to get on CNN.

2) You are bound to get better treatment. The reporters in Po Dunk, Idaho, aren't going to ask you about the Bush Doctrine. They want to know how you will help Potato farmers. It's far easier to bridge to your Alaska story and connect as one of them.

Even better, most local reporters would be thrilled at the chance to interview a VP candidate. They will be so hungry to have a VP candidate you'd be able to demand more concessions.

Palin hack: We want the pimply face intern to do the interview, and he will use the governor's questions.

Pimply faced intern: Yaay!

3) You get practice, so you are ready for the big guns. You don't do your first big interviews with the top anchors of the big three networks, silly. Do I really need to tell you that? You can't learn on that scale. You haven't had an opportunity to feel your way around, learn your style. Worse yet, EVERY BODY is watching. Fifteen to twenty interviews under your belt (that are picked up nationally), you might have the confidence you need to stare down Katie with bubbly defiance. As an added bonus, nobody would care. Nobody is Tivoing, rushing home to see you or YouTubing your 20th interview. By the time Charlie peers over his spectacles, it would be part of the noise.

Of course, I'm sure they won't listen. They will lock her in her cage until it's time to parade her in front of the next conservative crowd....while the wolves and the spotlight wait. Just my $.02